About Us

Welcome! We’re glad you’ve found us. Young & old(er), single & married, doubting & believing, we are all welcome. At First United Methodist Church, we are sharing life’s joys and challenges and growing in faith together along the way. Family-friendly worship for all ages is at the heart of our community, and there are many ways for you to connect and get involved outside of worship. Enjoy getting to know us as you explore our website, contact us if you have any questions, and come visit us soon!

Mission, Vision & Values

The mission of First United Methodist Church is to make disciples who share God’s love with all people and minister to their needs.
Our vision for family-friendly ministry is to equip families to grow together in Christ.
Our core values for ministry are:
* Welcome all people & families
* Keep Christ and the Word of God at the center of all ministry.
* Empower people to care for other people

Staff & Leadership

Terry Cavanaugh

Karen Deao

Administrative Assistant

Mike Ditty


Debbie Weyrick

Choir Director

Frequently Asked Questions

Do you have a question that’s not answered here? Contact us to ask it! Click Here

Do you have a Nursery? 

Yes. Children of all ages are always welcome in worship at First United Methodist Church. However, we also offer a volunteer-staffed Nursery for infants and toddlers. Our volunteers all complete Safe Sanctuary training and undergo criminal background screening to ensure the safety of your children. You may occasionally find student helpers in the Nursery who have also completed our Safe Sanctuary training along with Red Cross or other child care certification. The Nursery is located on the Main Level, just across the hallway along the west side of the sanctuary.

What does “family-friendly worship” mean?

“Family-friendly” means that we are striving to make worship an experience that people of all ages living in all kinds of families find meaningful and worthwhile. Young or old(er), single or married, we all belong in the church, and at First United Methodist Church, we know that worship is the place where we can best learn to become God’s family together. So whoever you are, whatever your life circumstances, Family-Friendly Worship at First UMC is for you!

What if my children are squirmy or noisy?

Great! God put the wiggle and the giggle in kids. We believe God is pleased when children are allowed to be children — especially in worship. One of the most important things we all (kids and adults) need to “get” out of worship is the experience of being God’s family together. At the same time, we understand that it can be hard for parents to worship with the wiggles in the next seat. 

What should I wear?

Clothes would be nice! We want you to be comfortable. If that means you want to wear a tie, feel free to do so, if jeans go for it, you’ll be welcome, no matter what you wear.


First United Methodist Church has a long and rich history in Greenville Ohio. The church has experienced tragedy and triumph: destruction by fire, the glory of new bells, and the hard work of remodeling.
1818 Methodist circuit riders served parts of Preble, Darke, Miami, & Montgomery Counties
1833 first frame church built across Sycamore St from present church
1852 brick church built, replacing the former one
1870 brick church remodeled and enlarged
1874 (or 1875) bell tower added
June 16, 1895 fire destroyed the building
April 21, 1896 cornerstone of present church laid at 4th St & Sycamore St
1907 new bells installed in bell tower
1920’s basement completed and kitchen added
1958 education wing added
1961 sanctuary remodeled
1998 elevator and additional bathrooms added
2015 flooding in the basement, resulting in current remodeling of classrooms
The church is never static, always changing. That’s because the church isn’t a building – the church is the people who gather to share life, grow in faith, and practice ministry together. First United Methodist Church is a hometown, community church. We work with strategic partners in Greenville and Darke County to promote the good of our community and world. We hope you’ll consider being a part of the history we’re making together today!